Proving Knowledge Of An Std Exists
In order to be charged with this crime, it has to be proven that you were fully aware that you were infected with an STD at the time intercourse occurred. Knowledge of an STD can be proven by prosecutors in two ways:
- Having received a positive diagnosis of an STD by a medical professional
- Signs of an STD were present for example, a herpes rash was obvious. This is referred to as constructive knowledge
The Miami Criminal Lawyer at our law firm has years of experience handing all types of criminal cases, including Unlawful Sexual Intercourse with STD.
Can My Partner Be Found Guilty Of Negligence
For wrongful infection of an STD based on negligence, it must be shown that the defendant failed to act as a âreasonable personâ would have under the same or similar circumstances.Examples of this could include failing to inform a sexual partner about having genital herpes before engaging in sexual intercourse when the defendant knew or should have known they had an STD.
Not disclosing an STD can be considered tantamount to unconsented sex.
Negligence does not require malice or ill intent. A person can still be negligent even though they used protection like a condom. They can still be liable for damages if they infect you with an STD that they failed to disclose to you.
If you have evidence linking your sexual partner to your STD, you may be able to file a civil lawsuit against them in order to seek compensation for medical costs and pain and suffering.Accordingly, if you have been injured by someone who knowingly or negligently transmitted an STD to you, you may be able to file a lawsuit against them.
Many negligent infection cases fall within the tort of battery by the defendant against the plaintiff. This is because negligent transmission is an actionable tort claim based on contact between two affectionate parties.
Itâs important to remember that you have a responsibility to both yourself and your partner to inform them of any potential risks before engaging in any sexual activity.
Where Would That Compensation Come From
In most cases, the transmitter would be held personally liable. This means they would pay the compensation out of their own pocket. Victims in these cases are unlikely to recover full compensation. Most people who transmit herpes cannot afford the costs of a court judgment.
In some cases, though, the transmitters homeowners insurance will provide coverage. Some homeowners insurance policies have broad liability provisions. These are meant to cover damages that are accidentally inflicted by the policyholder. They could extend to the transmission of an STD, including herpes.
Recommended Reading: Where Does Herpes Live In The Body
Is It Illegal To Not Tell Someone You Have Herpes
No, it is not illegal to not tell someone you have herpes. However, if you are in an intimate relationship with someone, it is best to let your partner know that you have an STD. This will allow you both to take precautions to minimize the spread of the STD.
It is also unlikely that you would win a case if you sued someone for infecting you with herpes. Oral herpes is often transmitted through non-sexual contact. Many people who are infected do not even know they have the disease. Unlike many other states, Arizona does not have specific laws that criminalize the spreading of an STD. While there have beensome attempts to make it a crime, as of 2020, the action was still not criminalized.
While you are not legally required to let people know you have herpes, it may be possible that you could get in legal trouble for speeding the disease in certain circumstances. InArizona, it is amisdemeanor offense to knowingly expose someone else to a contagious disease or infection in a public place. This means that you have to knowingly expose others and it has to be in a public place. This is unlikely to be the case for herpes, where most transmissions of the disease occur in a private setting.
You May Like: How Quickly Do Herpes Sores Appear
Why Would I Want To Sue My Sexual Partner For Giving Me An Std
Since you were not aware at the time that your partner was infected, you may consider taking legal action and suing your former sexual partner who infected you with an STD.
Most people know that it is wrong to knowingly give someone an STD. While the personal reasons for taking a former partner to court varies, some people are motivated to bring a cause of action because:
- It may prevent the infected person from infecting others
- If you can prove fault, you may be entitled to monetary damages
- It prevents the spread of the disease and creates awareness
Read Also: How To Rid Of Herpes
When Should I Hire A Personal Injury Lawyer
Mark Roman | November 11, 2022 | Personal Injury
Suffering injuries after an accident can be traumatic and life-altering. Victims in serious accidents carry the burden of their injuries along with financial losses and emotional distress. If a victim seeks to recover from insurance, adjusters at these companies can be another contributing factor to a victims stress following their accident. Insurance claims adjusters seekread more
Can You Sue Someone For Giving You An Std
Contracting an STD from your partner is probably the last thing youd want to have happen. Not only will it likely strain your relationship, but now youve got to deal with the disease itself.
If youve contracted an STD, can you sue the partner that gave it to you? While each states laws may vary to a degree, there are legal actions you can take against your partner.
In this article, well examine the question of can you sue someone for giving you an STD? in greater detail. Well look at some of the legal recourse and factors to consider if you ever contract an STD from someone.
Recommended Reading: Can You Kill Herpes Virus
Under Florida Tort Laws Can A Person Be Sued For Giving Someone A Sexually Transmitted Disease
- Posted on Sep 26, 2008
Yes, and transmission of certain STDs can constitute a criminal act. See Florida Statute 384.24. I actually just resolved a case where my client’s boyfriend gave her genital herpes. However, there are difficult pitfalls involved in these cases. For example, you must be able to prove the person giving the STD knew they had it at the time they transmitted it. The other problem is that almost all insurance policies that may cover this type of tort have an exclusion for intentional or criminal acts. Some policies specifically exclude coverage for transmission of STDs. So, if you sue and there is no insurance and the person has no collectible assets, you may just be spending alot of time and money to get a worthless judgment.
What Happens When You Sue Someone For Giving You An Std
According to the law, if the defendant is found guilty of giving you an STD, they are sentenced to pay fines and undergo punishments according to the severity of their actions. The punishment could range from paying minimum penalties to jail time or even prison sentences.
Every sexually active individual is responsible for getting tested for STDs from time to time to protect themselves and the people around them. If you are diagnosed with an STD, the first thing you should do is:
You May Like: How You Get Tested For Herpes
Criminal Versus Civil Court
The law of the state you live in determines whether transmitting herpes to another person may be considered a crime or only a matter of civil law, or both.
Criminal court
In states where transmitting herpes to another person can be a crime in the right circumstances, it is punishable with imprisonment or a fine.
When someone files a criminal complaint, the police will investigate and collect evidence.
If you transmitted herpes knowingly , you can be found guilty of a misdemeanor, which is punishable with up to one year of imprisonment or a fine .
Civil court
In most states, if you knowingly pass an infection to another person, you can be sued for monetary damages under common law tort principles.
When making a decision, civil courts rely on economic, ethical, and legal principles, including previous similar cases.
Wrongful Transmission Of Sexually Transmitted Disease
Many states have legislation that requires that people with certain STDs disclose their status to partners before having any sexual encounter. These laws make it a criminal offense for an infected person to engage in sexual intercourse without disclosure of their status.
In such states, it would be easier to prove the liability when you sue someone for giving you an STD. This is especially the case when the STD is HIV.
For example in Florida, not declaring HIV status in sexual relations that are consensual, when donating organs or blood or engaging in sexual work is a Felony offense of the third-degree that can lead to the possibility of up to 5 years in prison, and up to an amount of $5,000 in fines.
Recommended Reading: Blood Test For Herpes 1 And 2
What Goes Into A Demand Letter:
If you are unsure of what to include in your demand letter to the other party, don’t worry. You will want to include the following:
- How much money you are owed
- Why you are owed money
- Your contact information
- Give them a few days to respond
- State that if they don’t respond, you intend to sue
You will want to mail the letter to the other person in order to give them the best chance at fixing the problem. Dispute can help you generate and send a demand letter via 2-day priority mail in just 5 minutes from your phone or computer as well.
Types Of Damages For Std
Is it illegal to transmit an STD? If you know you have an STD, then it might be illegal to fail to disclose it to your sexual partner. However, it can prove very challenging to gather proof of the damages caused by an STD. STDs do not always develop immediately, and your body may not show any signs for a long time. If you happen to have other sexual partners during this time, it will complicate the situation further.
Some of the different types of damages for STD-related charges include:
- Pain and suffering Monetary damages to compensate for the pain felt
- Medical expenses Expenses related to medical costs for treating the STD
- Emotional distress Damages related to the fear and anxiety felt after learning you contracted the STD
Read Also: How To Cure Herpes Fast
Punishment For Transmitting An Std In New York
Indulging in sexual activities while infected is a misdemeanor in New York the person found guilty may face a sentence to jail of one year and a fine of up to $1,000.
In severe cases, such as reckless endangerment, which is a class D felony, the person found guilty may be punished with a sentence to jail for up to 7 years and a fine of up to $5,000.
Recommended Reading: What Medication Treats Genital Herpes
Everything Comes Down To These Questions
In both criminal and civil cases, the outcome will depend on the answers to the following questions:
1. Did the defendant know they have an STD?
2. Did the defendant take reasonable steps to discover the condition?
3. If the defendant was hiding the information, was it intentional or inadvertent?
4. Did the defendant take reasonable and available steps to minimize the risk of transmission?
5. Did the plaintiff or complainant recently acquire the infection?
6. Did they get it from the defendant ?
Letâs talk about each part and the complexity of proving it.
1. Did the defendant know they have an STD?
The plaintiff or the state will have to prove that the defendant knew they had the infection.
2. Unless the defendant admits it, documentation of past lab testing will have to be obtained. There is no universal data center from which to request those results.
Did the defendant take reasonable steps to discover the condition?
Herpes is not a condition that is routinely tested for, and the CDC doesnât advise testing.
Testing occurs mainly when the person has symptoms to rule out other condition and to determine the cause of skin lesions.
3. If the defendant was hiding the information, was it intentional or inadvertent?
If the defendant knew about the condition and hid the information from their partner, thatâs considered an intentional harm.
If the defendant forgot to tell their partner about the condition, itâs considered negligence.
6. Did they get it from the defendant ?
Read Also: How Do You Contract Herpes Std
You Cant Sue Your Spouse For Giving You An Std In Illinois But There Are Still Options
It doesnt mean that you cant sue your spouse for giving you a sexually transmitted disease in Illinois divorce court, just because you cant sue in another state. The only risky behaviors that can be punished in Illinois are those carried out by people who have HIV or other STDs. Despite the fact that IllinoisSTD laws apply only to HIV, other crimes may occur if an individual is exposed to it. The fact that your partner knew they had an STD but did not inform you or continue having sex with you is considered intentional exposure. Whether you live in a city or country, your partner is legally responsible for failing to inform you about their STDs.
The Consequences Of Failing To Inform Your Partner
The consequences of failing to inform your partner can be twofold:
You May Like: How To Take Valacyclovir For Herpes
What Type Of Std Can You Sue Someone For
There are around 20 sexually transmitted diseases some are treatable, while others are not. According to the law, you cannot sue someone over every type of STD you contracted after sexual relations with them.
With the help of an STD lawsuit, you can seek compensation for the transmission of:
- Chronic Hepatitis B
The type of STD you can file a lawsuit for may vary depending on the states rules. An attorney would be the best person to talk to know if you can sue someone for the type of STD or STI you have contracted from them.
The Dangers Of Genital Herpes
Genital herpes may cause painful ulcers that can be severe and persistent in patients. Both HSV-1 and HSV-2 can also cause rare but serious complications such as aseptic meningitis . Development of extragenital lesions may occur during the course of infection.
Many people who contract HSV-2 have concerns about how it will impact their overall health, sex life, and relationships. There is significant mental trauma that comes with a diagnosis of Herpes. Considerable embarrassment, shame, and stigma associated with a herpes diagnosis oftentimes severely interferes with a patients psyche.
Pregnant women face additional dangers from genital herpes, as HSV-2 can be passed on to their baby during childbirth.
Don’t Miss: Is Herpes Transmitted Through Blood
Can You Sue Someone For Giving You Herpes Or Other Stds
Sex always comes with the risk of contracting diseases, even in monogamous relationships. The CDC reports that herpes is a commonly transmitted disease that can pass between people even when they use a condom and when there are no visible breakouts. This is why voluntary disclosure or an honest response to a direct question regarding STD status is so important. Unfortunately, many people are embarrassed by their STD status. There are also many malicious parties who deliberately pass the disease on to others. If you contracted herpes, or another STI from someone, learn about your options if you want to sue them for giving it to you.
What Are Specific Causes Of Action
Many states recognize wrongful infection or transmission of an STD as its own cause of action. Additionally, while there are no federal laws that require a person to disclose they have an STD, there are state laws regarding telling sexual partners if you have certain STDs, such as HIV/AIDS or herpes.
For example, in California, itâs considered a felony for an individual who is HIV-positive to engage in unprotected sex, fail to tell their partner about their status, or engage in sex with the intent to infect their partner. If found guilty, the person can face up to eight years in prison.
Recommended Reading: Genital Herpes Treatments Over The Counter
Recommended Reading: Does Herpes Mean You Have Hiv
What Are Stds And Stis: Are They The Same
STDs are sexually transmitted diseases, and STIs are sexually transmitted infections. But no matter which term people use, they talk about the same thing. STDs and STIs get transferred from one person to another from sexual activities, including intercourse.
There are multiple types of STDs and STIs, including chlamydia and HIV. According to the court of law, you cannot file a lawsuit against someone for every type of STD or STI. But most severe STDs like HIV/AIDs let you sue someone and get compensation for the damages caused to your physical well-being and financial health.
If A Sexual Partner Had Knowledge Of His/her Std And Infected You He Or She May Be Liable For Damages In A Civil Lawsuit
By David Goguen, J.D.
If you have been infected with a sexually transmitted disease ,you may be able to file a civil lawsuit against the sexual partner whoinfected you. And in rare cases, even if you were not actually infected,you still may be able to hold the other person liable for the emotionaltrauma caused by the threat of exposure.
There are a number of different legal theories that you may be able to rely on in bringing a civil lawsuit for STD infection.The right legal theory will depend on the circumstances of yoursituation, but two of the most common theories are negligence and civilbattery.
By Erin Danly
Getting or transmitting a sexually transmitted disease is not only a health matter it could be a legal matter, too. Though laws vary greatly from state to state, most states have laws regarding the disclosure of health status, the transmission of STDs, and the handling of confidential medical information. Read on to find out more.
You may face criminal charges for passing an STD to someone else.
Compared to a civil case, a successful criminal case requires more substantial evidence. In many states, punishments include jail time and high fines.
You may face civil charges for passing an STD to someone else.
Related: Can you get sued for an STD?
Even if you used protection, you can be sued.
Read Also: How To Clear Up Oral Herpes Fast